Having someone tell you “you stole my heart” can be a beautiful thing. This romantic phrase is often used to express admiration, gratitude, or romantic feelings towards someone. However, it can also catch you off guard and leave you wondering how to respond.
While it’s often said lightly or as a sweet sentiment, hearing someone say you’ve stolen their heart can feel like a lot of pressure. You may not be ready to reciprocate those emotions. Or you might worry about leading someone on if you don’t feel the same way.
Don’t panic if this compliment catches you off guard! Here are 35 replies you can use when someone says “you stole my heart” in different situations:
35 replies When Someone Says You Stole My Heart
1. I appreciate the compliment.
2. I’m flattered to hear you say that.
3. You’re very kind, thank you.
4. I enjoy spending time with you too.
5. Let’s see where this goes.
6. I’ll take good care of it.
7. You may want it back someday.
8. I hope your heart is insured.
9. I don’t accept stolen goods.
10. I’ll give you a receipt for it.
11. We should get to know each other better.
12. You have my heart as well.
13. You have my heart always.
14. I didn’t realize I was a thief.
15. Does this mean I’m going to jail?
16. You gave it to me willingly.
17. You broke into my heart too.
18. We’re both guilty of stealing hearts.
19. That’s so sweet, thank you.
20. You should be jailed for that line.
21. I’m keeping it.
22. I’ll guard your heart.
23. We both stole each other’s hearts.
24. No, you gave it away freely.
25. Don’t worry, it’s in safe hands.
26. Oh, I wasn’t aware of that.
27. When did this happen?
28. What should we do about this?
29. Do you want your heart back?
30. Aww, I love you too!
31. Aww, thanks a lot!
32. I’m really pleased to hear that.
33. I’m glad I stole your heart.
34. Stealing hearts is what I do best.
35. Wow, lovely to know!
What To Reply When Someone Says You Stole My Heart?
1. I appreciate the compliment.
When someone says “you stole my heart”, it is meant as a compliment expressing love or admiration. Thanking them for the kind words shows your gratitude.
2. I’m flattered to hear you say that.
Hearing someone say you stole their heart can make you feel admired. Letting them know their words made you feel flattered is a polite response.
3. You’re very kind, thank you.
Calling them kind returns the sweetness of their remark. Saying thanks emphasizes your appreciation for their compliment.
4. I enjoy spending time with you too.
Replying that you enjoy their company as well tells them you like being around them. It’s a positive response if you share their feelings.
5. Let’s see where this goes.
This leaves the door open to getting to know each other better romantically. It indicates potential interest in a relationship.
6. I’ll take good care of it.
Promising to take care of their heart implies you intend to treat them with care and affection. It shows you reciprocate their feelings.
7. You may want it back someday.
This playfully warns them not to get too attached. It’s a gentle way to decline romantic interest if you don’t share their feelings.
8. I hope your heart is insured.
Making light of the situation, this reply jokingly suggests their heart is in risky hands. It adds humor if you want to be evasive.
9. I don’t accept stolen goods.
A clever response, this wittily refuses unwanted romantic advances by taking their words literally.
10. I’ll give you a receipt for it.
Amusingly following up on the theft motif, this implies you’ll provide proof you accepted their heart. It injects humor into the exchange.
11. We should get to know each other better.
Suggesting you take more time to get to know each other leaves room for a possible future relationship. It’s a polite response to someone you just met.
12. You have my heart as well.
Telling them they equally have your heart expresses mutual romantic feelings. It’s a sweet response if you feel the same way about them.
13. You have my heart always.
Declaring they will always have your heart affirms your lasting love and commitment to them. It’s an appropriate reply for a spouse or partner.
14. I didn’t realize I was a thief.
Playing innocent, this response cutely pretends surprise at stealing their heart. It’s a flirty and clever response accepting their compliment.
15. Does this mean I’m going to jail?
Humorously taking the theft motif further, this reply jokingly asks about facing consequences. It injects playfulness into the conversation.
16. You gave it to me willingly.
Kindly reframing it, this response emphasizes it was a willing gesture on their part. It stresses your care for their feelings.
17. You broke into my heart too.
Indicating reciprocation, this reply playfully accuses them back. It affirms mutual romantic feelings.
18. We’re both guilty of stealing hearts.
Accusing both of you lightheartedly implies you’re both falling for each other. It confirms shared romantic interest.
19. That’s so sweet, thank you.
Thanking them for the kind words acknowledges the compliment. Saying it’s sweet expresses you’re touched by the sentiment.
20. You should be jailed for that line.
A witty response, this mocks their words while still keeping things humorous. It gently declines unwanted advances.
21. I’m keeping it.
Saying you’re keeping their heart implies you intend to hold on to their love. It’s a sweet way to reciprocate romantic feelings.
22. I’ll guard your heart.
Promising to guard their heart suggests you’ll protect them from emotional harm. It shows your affection and care for their wellbeing.
23. We both stole each other’s hearts.
This playfully implies you’ve mutually fallen for one another. It’s a lighthearted way to convey shared romantic interest.
24. No, you gave it away freely.
This counters the theft notion by saying they willingly surrendered their heart. It’s a coy way to address unwanted advances.
25. Don’t worry, it’s in safe hands.
Reassuring them implies you’ll cherish their heart without taking advantage. It’s a tactful reply if you want to be noncommittal.
26. Oh, I wasn’t aware of that.
Feigning unawareness can gentle deflect unwanted interest without embarrassment. It allows you to avoid an outright rejection.
27. When did this happen?
Asking for details expresses surprise at their declaration. It allows you to process the information and formulate an appropriate response.
28. What should we do about this?
This playfully ponders next steps, inviting them to clarify their intentions. It stalls while you determine how to respond.
29. Do you want your heart back?
Turning the tables, this asks if they’re having second thoughts. It’s a cheeky response if you want to deflect romantic interest.
30. Aww, I love you too!
When said sincerely, this warmly reciprocates their feelings. It’s an enthusiastic response if you share their romantic sentiment.
31. Aww, thanks a lot!
Expressing gratitude acknowledges the kind words. Saying “Aww” conveys being touched by the sentiment.
32. I’m really pleased to hear that.
Letting them know you’re pleased affirms their words delighted you. It’s a polite response to an admirer.
33. I’m glad I stole your heart.
This playfully owns up to capturing their heart. It shows pride in winning their affection.
34. Stealing hearts is what I do best.
A cheeky response, this jokingly embraces the idea you’re skilled at winning affection. It adds playful arrogance.
35. Wow, lovely to know!
This expresses awed delight at their confession. It warmly validates their feelings without reciprocity.
FAQ
Q: What does it mean when someone says “you stole my heart”?
A: This romantic phrase is a way of telling someone that they have captured your admiration, affection, or love in a way that makes you happy. It expresses that you have strong romantic feelings and happiness when spending time with that person. The phrase implies that the person has figuratively stolen your heart without you even realizing it.
Q: How should you respond when someone says “you stole my heart”?
There are many sweet responses and different ways you can answer this compliment. You can reciprocate romantic feelings by saying “you have my heart too” or “I’m keeping it”. Or you can playfully joke “am I going to jail for this perfect crime?” There’s no single right thing to say – tailor your response to your relationship with the person.
Q: Is “you stole my heart” an unhealthy sentiment?
A: No, this phrase does not inherently signal toxic relationships. In healthy relationships, people uses this phrase a lot. Problems only arise if someone feels pressured by the sentiment. As long as both people enter the relationship willingly, the phrase can represent a beautiful thing.
Q: What does it mean to truly steal someone’s heart?
A: To steal someone’s heart in the sense of popular romantic phrases is to win it over through love. But in reality, no one can forcibly take someone’s capacity to love – that is always a gift freely given. We cultivate love by choosing each day to be our best selves.
Q: How can you tell if someone genuinely means “you stole my heart?”
A: Look for other signs that this person admires and cares for you – do they make time for you? Show gratitude? Remember little things about you? Express themselves openly? True feelings reveal themselves through actions, not just words. But give the benefit of the doubt – take the phrase as a compliment.
Wrap Up
When someone confessionally tells you, “you stole my heart,” it’s a big compliment. This common romantic phrase expresses admiration, gratitude, and strong feelings of affection. However, it can also take you by surprise and leave you wondering how to react.
Hopefully, this post has provided some helpful ways to respond depending on the context and your relationship with the person.
The most important thing is to be true to your own feelings. If you genuinely return their admiration and romantic interest, reciprocate warmly. But if you don’t, don’t feel pressured to match their intensity. A simple “thank you” acknowledging the compliment is perfectly fine. Just respond genuinely and let that sincerity show through in your words and actions.
